|
|
HBill.html
04 LC 34 0076S
COMMITTEE OF CONFERENCE
SUBSTITUTE TO SB 157
A BILL TO BE
ENTITLED AN ACT
To amend Code Section 7-3-29 of the Official Code of Georgia
Annotated, relating to penalties for violations of the "Georgia Industrial Loan
Act," so as to allow class actions to be brought against unlicensed lenders; to
amend Title 16 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to crimes and
offenses, so as to include payday lending in the definition of racketeering
activity; to declare a legislative intent to prohibit activities commonly
referred to as payday lending, deferred presentment services, or advance cash
services and other similar activities; to strengthen and increase the criminal
and civil penalties therefor; to void payday lending loans; to declare that
forum selection clauses in payday lending contracts are unenforceable in
Georgia; to provide that it shall be unlawful to engage in the business of
making certain small loans; to provide for exemptions for licensed and regulated
activities; to define crimes and declare penalties; to provide for civil
remedies of borrowers; to provide for civil penalties; to provide for collection
of civil penalties in actions by the state or by private parties; to declare a
tax on profits from payday loans; to declare sites or locations on which payday
lending is taking place to be public nuisances; to provide disclosure and notice
requirements regarding loans made to members of the military; to provide for
severability; to provide for related matters; to provide an effective date; to
repeal conflicting laws; and for other purposes.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF
GEORGIA:
SECTION 1.
Code Section 7-3-29 of the Official Code of Georgia
Annotated, relating to penalties for violations of the "Georgia Industrial Loan
Act," is amended by striking subsection (e) and inserting in its place the
following: "(e)
A claim of violation of this chapter against a duly licensed lender may
be asserted in an individual action only and may not be the subject of a class
action under Code Section 9-11-23 or any other provision of law. A claim of
violation of this chapter against an unlicensed lender may be asserted in a
class action under Code Section 9-11-23 or any other provision of
law."
SECTION 2.
Title 16 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating
to crimes and offenses, is amended in Code Section 16-14-3, relating to
definitions concerning racketeer influenced organizations, by striking divisions
(9)(A)(xxxvi) and (9)(A)(xxxvii) and inserting in lieu thereof the
following: "(xxxvi)
Article 8 of Chapter 9 of this title, relating to identity fraud, and Section
1028 of Title 18 of the United States Code, relating to fraudulent
identification documents and information;
or (xxxvii) Code Section 33-1-9,
relating to insurance fraud.;
or (xxxviii) Code Section 16-17-2, relating to
payday loans."
SECTION 3.
Said title is further amended by adding a new Chapter 17 to
read as follows:
"CHAPTER
17
16-17-1. (a) Without limiting
in any manner the scope of this chapter, 'payday lending' as used in this
chapter encompasses all transactions in which funds are advanced to be repaid at
a later date, notwithstanding the fact that the transaction contains one or more
other elements and a 'payday lender' shall be one who engages in such
transactions. This definition of 'payday lending' expressly incorporates the
exceptions and examples contained in subsections (a) and (b) of Code Section
16-17-2. (b) Despite the fact that the Attorney
General of the State of Georgia has opined in Official Opinion 2002-3 entered on
June 27, 2002, that payday lending is in violation of Georgia law and despite
the fact that the Industrial Loan Commissioner has issued cease and desist
orders against various payday lenders in the State of Georgia, the General
Assembly has determined that payday lending continues in the State of Georgia
and that there are not sufficient deterrents in the State of Georgia to cause
this illegal activity to cease. (c) The General
Assembly has determined that various payday lenders have created certain schemes
and methods in order to attempt to disguise these transactions or to cause these
transactions to appear to be 'loans' made by a national or state bank chartered
in another state in which this type of lending is unregulated, even though the
majority of the revenues in this lending method are paid to the payday lender.
The General Assembly has further determined that payday lending, despite the
illegality of such activity, continues to grow in the State of Georgia and is
having an adverse effect upon military personnel, the elderly, the economically
disadvantaged, and other citizens of the State of Georgia. The General Assembly
has further determined that substantial criminal and civil penalties over and
above those currently existing under state law are necessary in order to
prohibit this activity in the State of Georgia and to cause the cessation of
this activity once and for all. The General Assembly further declares that these
types of loans are currently illegal and are in violation of Code Section 7-4-2.
The General Assembly declares that the use of agency or partnership agreements
between in-state entities and out-of-state banks, whereby the in-state agent
holds a predominant economic interest in the revenues generated by payday loans
made to Georgia residents, is a scheme or contrivance by which the agent seeks
to circumvent Chapter 3 of Title 7, the 'Georgia Industrial Loan Act,' and the
usury statutes of this state. (d) Payday lending
involves relatively small loans and does not encompass loans that involve
interstate commerce and certain payday lenders have attempted to use forum
selection clauses contained in payday loan documents in order to avoid the
courts of the State of Georgia, and the General Assembly has determined that
such practices are unconscionable and should be
prohibited. (e) Without limiting in any manner the
scope of this chapter, the General Assembly declares that it is the general
intent of this chapter to reiterate that in the State of Georgia the practice of
engaging in activities commonly referred to as payday lending, deferred
presentment services, or advance cash services and other similar activities are
currently illegal and to strengthen the penalties for those engaging in such
activities. (f) This chapter in no way impairs or
restricts the authority granted to the commissioner of banking and finance, the
Industrial Loan Commissioner, or any other regulatory authority with concurrent
jurisdiction over the matters stated in this
chapter.
16-17-2. (a) It
shall be unlawful for any person to engage in any business, in whatever form
transacted, including, but not limited to, by mail, electronic, the Internet, or
telephonic means, which consists in whole or in part of making, offering,
arranging, or acting as an agent in the making of loans of $3,000.00 or less
unless: (1) Such person is engaging in financial
transactions permitted pursuant to: (A) The laws
regulating financial institutions as defined under Chapter 1 of Title 7, the
'Financial Institutions Code of Georgia'; (B) The laws
regulating state and federally chartered credit
unions; (C) Article 13 of Chapter 1 of Title 7,
relating to Georgia residential mortgages; (D) Chapter
3 of Title 7, the 'Georgia Industrial Loan Act'; (E)
Chapter 4 of Title 7, relating to interest and
usury; (F) Chapter 5 of Title 7, 'The Credit Card and
Credit Card Bank Act,' including financial institutions and their assignees who
are not operating in violation of said chapter; or (G)
Paragraph (2) of subsection (a) of Code Section 7-4-2 in which the simple
interest rate is not greater than 16 percent per
annum; (2) Such loans are lawful under the terms
of: (A) Article 1 of Chapter 1 of Title 10, 'The
Retail Installment and Home Solicitation Sales
Act'; (B) Article 2 of Chapter 1 of Title 10, the
'Motor Vehicle Sales Finance Act'; or (C) Part 5 of
Article 3 of Chapter 12 of Title 44, relating to
pawnbrokers; (3) Subject to the provisions of
paragraph (4) of subsection (b) of this Code section, such person is a bank or
thrift chartered under the laws of the United States, a bank chartered under the
laws of another state and insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation,
or a credit card bank and is not operating in violation of the federal and state
laws applicable to its charter; or (4) Such loan is
made as a tax refund anticipation loan. In order to be exempt under this
paragraph the tax refund anticipation loan must be issued using a
borrower´s filed tax return and the loan cannot be for more than the amount
of the borrower´s anticipated tax refund. Tax returns that are prepared but
not filed with the proper government agency will not qualify for a loan
exemption under this paragraph. (b) Subject to the
exceptions in subsection (a) of this Code section, this Code section shall apply
with respect to all transactions in which funds are advanced to be repaid at a
later date, notwithstanding the fact that the transaction contains one or more
other elements. Without limiting the generality of the foregoing, the advance
of funds to be repaid at a later date shall be subject to this Code section,
notwithstanding the fact that the transaction also
involves: (1) The cashing or deferred presentment of a
check or other instrument; (2) The selling or
providing of an item, service, or commodity incidental to the advance of
funds; (3) Any other element introduced to disguise
the true nature of the transaction as an extension of credit;
or (4) Any arrangement by which a de facto lender
purports to act as the agent for an exempt entity. A purported agent shall be
considered a de facto lender if the entire circumstances of the transaction show
that the purported agent holds, acquires, or maintains a predominant economic
interest in the revenues generated by the loan. (c)(1)
A payday lender shall not include in any loan contract made with a resident of
this state any provision by which the laws of a state other than Georgia shall
govern the terms and enforcement of the contract, nor shall the loan contract
designate a court for the resolution of disputes concerning the contract other
than a court of competent jurisdiction in and for the county in which the
borrower resides or the loan office is located. (2) An
arbitration clause in a payday loan contract shall not be enforceable if the
contract is unconscionable. In determining whether the contract is
unconscionable, the court shall consider the circumstances of the transaction as
a whole, including but not limited to: (A) The
relative bargaining power of the parties; (B) Whether
arbitration would be prohibitively expensive to the borrower in view of the
amounts in controversy; (C) Whether the contract
restricts or excludes damages or remedies that would be available to the
borrower in court, including the right to participate in a class
action; (D) Whether the arbitration would take place
outside the county in which the loan office is located or any other place that
would be unduly inconvenient or expensive in view of the amounts in controversy;
and (E) Any other circumstance that might render the
contract oppressive. (d) Any person who violates
subsection (a) or (b) of this Code section shall be guilty of a misdemeanor of a
high and aggravated nature and upon conviction thereof shall be punished by
imprisonment for not more than one year or by a fine not to exceed $5,000.00 or
both. Each loan transaction shall be deemed a separate violation of this Code
section. Any person who aids or abets such a violation, including any arbiter or
arbitration company, shall likewise be guilty of a misdemeanor of a high and
aggravated nature and shall be punished as set forth in this subsection. If a
person has been convicted of violations of subsection (a) or (b) of this Code
section on three prior occasions, then all subsequent convictions shall be
considered felonies punishable by a fine of $10,000.00 or five years
imprisonment or
both.
16-17-3. Any person
who violates subsection (a) or (b) of Code Section 16-17-2 shall be barred from
the collection of any indebtedness created by said loan transaction and said
transaction shall be void ab initio, and any person violating the provisions of
subsection (a) or (b) of Code Section 16-17-2 shall in addition be liable to the
borrower in each unlawful transaction for three times the amount of any interest
or other charges to the borrower. A civil action under Code Section 16-17-2 may
be brought on behalf of an individual borrower or on behalf of an ascertainable
class of borrowers. In a successful action to enforce the provisions of this
chapter, a court shall award a borrower, or class of borrowers, costs including
reasonable attorneys´
fees.
16-17-4. (a) Any
person who violates subsection (a) or (b) of Code Section 16-17-2 shall be
liable to the state for a civil penalty equal to three times the amount of any
interest or charges to the borrowers in the unlawful
transactions. (b) A civil action under Code Section
16-17-2 may be brought by the Attorney General, any district attorney, or a
private party. Where a successful civil action is brought by a district
attorney one-half of the damages recovered on behalf of the state shall be
distributed to the office of the district attorney of the judicial circuit of
such district attorney to be used by the district attorney in order to fund the
budget of that
office.
16-17-5. (a)
There is imposed a state tax on all loans made in violation of this chapter.
Such tax shall be administered and collected in connection with the Georgia
income taxation of the person making such loans and shall be in addition to any
other tax liability of such person. (b) The tax
imposed by this Code section shall be at the rate of 50 percent of all proceeds
received by a person from loans made in violation of this
chapter. (c) A person making loans in violation of
this chapter shall declare and return the proceeds subject to taxation under
this Code section as a part of such person´s Georgia income tax
return. (d) The state revenue commissioner shall
retain returns under this Code section apart from all other returns and shall
not disclose any part of such a return for any purpose other than the collection
of tax owed or a criminal prosecution involving tax matters. In a criminal
proceeding under this chapter, a person´s return of proceeds under this
Code section and any evidence derived as a result of such return shall not be
admissible.
16-17-6. In
regard to any loan transaction that is alleged to be in violation of subsection
(a) of Code Section 16-17-2, the trial court shall be authorized to review the
terms of the transaction in their entirety in order to determine if there has
been any contrivance, device, or scheme used by the lender in order to avoid the
provisions of subsection (a) of Code Section 16-17-2. The trial court shall not
be bound in making such determination by the parol evidence rule or by any
written contract but shall be authorized to determine exactly whether the loan
transaction includes the use of a scheme, device, or contrivance and whether in
reality the loan is in violation of the provisions of subsection (a) of Code
Section 16-17-2 based upon the facts and evidence relating to that transaction
and similar transactions being made in the State of Georgia. If any entity
involved in soliciting or facilitating the making of payday loans purports to be
acting as an agent of a bank or thrift, then the court shall be authorized to
determine whether the entity claiming to act as agent is in fact the lender.
Such entity shall be presumed to be the lender if, under the totality of the
circumstances, it holds, acquires, or maintains a predominant economic interest
in the revenues generated by the loan. Furthermore, the trial court shall
further be authorized to investigate all transactions involving gift cards,
telephone cards, the sale of goods or services, computer services, or the like
which may be tied to such loan transactions and are an integral part thereof in
order to determine whether any such transaction is in fact a contrivance,
scheme, or device used by the payday lender in order to evade the provisions of
subsection (a) of Code Section
16-17-2.
16-17-7. All
corporations, limited liability companies, or other business entities which are
engaged in payday lending in the State of Georgia are prohibited from obtaining
any certificate of authority from the Secretary of State or from the Department
of Banking and Finance and engaging in such payday lending activity in the State
of Georgia shall result in the revocation of any existing certificate of
authority.
16-17-8. The
site or location of a place of business where payday lending takes place in the
State of Georgia is declared a public
nuisance.
16-17-9. (a) In
addition to the other obligations and duties required under this chapter, if the
customer is a member of the military services of the United States or a spouse
of a member of the military services of the United States, the following duties
and obligations apply to any payday lender: (1) The
lender is prohibited from garnishment of any military wages or
salaries; (2) The lender is prohibited from conducting
any collection activity against a military customer or his or her spouse when
the military member has been deployed to a combat or combat support posting for
the duration of the deployment; (3) The lender is
prohibited from contacting the commanding officer of a military customer in an
effort to collect on a loan to the military member or his or her
spouse; (4) The lender agrees to be bound by the terms
of any repayment agreement that it negotiates through military counselors or
third-party credit counselors; and (5) The lender
agrees to honor any statement or proclamation by a military base commander that
a specific payday lender branch location has been declared off limits to
military personnel and their spouses. (b) If the
customer is a member of the military services of the United States or a spouse
of a member of the military services of the United States, the following
disclosures shall be made in writing by the payday
lender: (1) A notice that the lender is prohibited
from garnishment of any military wages or salaries; (2)
A notice that the lender is prohibited from conducting any collection activity
against a military customer or his or her spouse when the military member has
been deployed to a combat or combat support posting for the duration of the
deployment; (3) A notice that the lender is prohibited
from contacting the commanding officer of a military customer in an effort to
collect on a loan to the military member or his or her
spouse; (4) A notice that the lender agrees to be
bound by the terms of any repayment agreement that it negotiates through
military counselors or third-party credit counselors;
and (5) A notice that the lender agrees to honor any
statement or proclamation by a military base commander that a specific payday
lending branch location has been declared off limits to military personnel and
their spouses.
16-17-10.
If any provision of this chapter or the application of
such provision is found by a court of competent jurisdiction in the United
States to be invalid or is found to be superseded by federal law, then the
remaining provisions of this chapter shall not be affected, and this chapter
shall continue to apply to any other person or
circumstance."
SECTION 4.
This Act shall become effective on May 1,
2004.
SECTION 5.
All laws and parts of laws in conflict with this Act are
repealed.
|